Microsoft's data center project in Mount Pleasant, Wisconsin.
Joe Timmerman/Wisconsin Watch via Getty Images
The midterm backlash against AI data centers could help the biggest cloud providers.
Amazon, Microsoft, and Google have existing capacity that smaller rivals are racing to match.
Limits on new construction could reduce competition and push up AI computing prices.
The backlash against AI data centers delivered a stunning political upset in Tuesday's midterm elections. But the biggest winners may turn out to be the tech giants that have already built many of these
Voters across the US sent a clear message Tuesday: They want to slow or stop the construction of new data centers. That could make it much harder for the AI industry to keep up with soaring demand.
The biggest shock came in Texas, where Democrat Gina Hinojosa defeated Republican Gov. Greg Abbott. Hinojosa has promised to immediately pause data center development in a state that's home to some of America's largest AI projects.
Yet their shares jumped on Wednesday, while smaller AI cloud providers, including CoreWeave and Nebius, were hammered.
The divergence highlights an important consequence of the election results: Making new data centers harder to build could strengthen the biggest tech companies while crushing some of their smaller rivals.
Amazon, Google, and Microsoft already operate enormous networks of data centers packed with expensive Nvidia chips that power AI services, including those offered by OpenAI and Anthropic.
Smaller competitors are racing to catch up, investing billions of dollars in new facilities and computing equipment.
But if newer projects are delayed or canceled, these challengers could be stuck with expensive expansion plans while their larger rivals continue to make money from facilities already operating.
That would mean less competition for Amazon, Google, and Microsoft.
It could also mean higher prices.
With demand for AI computing power still booming, restrictions on new data centers could make existing capacity more valuable. That would mean even bigger profits for Amazon, Microsoft, and Google.
Paul Golding, a Macquarie analyst, highlighted this dynamic in a note to investors on Wednesday.
"Approved, permitted pipeline becomes far more valuable," he wrote, predicting that demand for increasingly scarce data center capacity could drive prices higher.
There's already evidence of this supply-demand phenomenon. Silicon Data, which tracks the cost of renting Nvidia GPUs through cloud services, has recorded steadily rising prices this year for several popular chips.
"If demand keeps growing and protests delay new capacity, that could certainly help support GPU rental pricing," Brad Gastwirth, global head of research at Circular Technology, told me.
The irony is striking.
Voters trying to rein in the AI data center boom may have just handed Amazon, Google, and Microsoft an even stronger grip on the industry.
The citizens of Harwood, who number about 940, shot down a measure that would have given residents a greater say in how large projects, such as AI data centers, are constructed in the town.
The vote wasn't exactly close, either. Some 325 voted against the measure, compared to 105 who voted for it, according to the North Dakota Secretary of State's office.
Of all 45 data-center-related propositions on the ballot across the country on Tuesday, Harwood stood out as the sole constituency in support of them. The other 44 fell on the anti-data-center side, according to Redbud Consulting, a ballot tracking firm.
And for residents of Harwood, the issue is germane. A $3 billion AI data center equal in size to 17 football fields is under construction in the community's backyard. The company building it hopes to employ 200 people — a number equal to about 20% of the city's population.
"It's frustrating," Mark Coolidge, a 59-year-old resident who voted for the measure, told Business Insider.
"We are the people that have to live with this type of industry as a neighbor," said Mike Swartz, a 47-year-old resident who advocated for the proposition. "Do we not have any say in what we want for the community some have vested decades into calling their home?"
In an interview, Blake Hankey, the mayor of Harwood, said he didn't support the measure. He said the language of the proposition was imprecise and that some of the stipulations "would have been financially burdensome to a city our size."
"This amendment to the home rule charter wasn't strictly aimed at data centers," he said. "It was any kind of business coming to town."
He also said the proposition wasn't a referendum on data centers. "It wasn't if there was going to be a moratorium," he added.
The proposition, should it have passed, would not have affected the existing data center, which is set to be completed next year.
Rather, it would have applied to all future construction projects that met a criteria of scale. For instance, a new gas station wouldn't have qualified, but a new large data center would be subject to independent assessments and mandatory public hearings.
Swartz said the measure was necessary because people in town were "blindsided" by how quickly the current data center was approved.
"Many in town didn't even know what that was or meant," he said. "Yet it only took 21 days from the time it was announced to the time construction began."
Hankey, who said he signed a non-disclosure agreement with Applied Digital, the company building the data center, described the decision as one he and the city council had to make quickly, lest neighboring Fargo got the contract first.
"I don't regret signing it," he said of the NDA. "Had I not, that data center would almost certainly be in the city of Fargo right now, without any kind of sales tax or property tax for our community."
As major developers, including SpaceX, Microsoft, Google, Amazon, OpenAI, and others, seek new AI data centers to power their products, they've encountered stiff resistance at town halls and city councils across the United States. Americans worry about the environmental impact, about electric bills, or the water supply. Many just don't like AI.
After a series of contentious city council meetings in Harwood, including one in which anti-data-center protesters were ejected by sheriffs, Coolidge said Swartz gathered enough signatures to formally put the proposition on the ballot.
Voters ultimately shot it down, Swartz and Coolidge said, in part because people in town disagreed with whether the measure would also apply to smaller buildings and businesses, rather than just large ones.
Applied Digital did not respond to a request for comment on Wednesday.
"It's all about money," Coolidge said. "They could give a rip about us as citizens."
Microsoft said third-party data center delays contributed to a shortfall in infrastructure spend.
Satellite imagery points to potential setbacks for the massive IREN and Nebius data center projects.
Neoclouds are under mounting pressure to deliver on their multibillion-dollar promises.
Microsoft spent $5 billion less than expected on AI last quarter, and satellite images may show why.
In Microsoft's quarterly earnings call last month, chief financial officer Amy Hood said delays by third-party cloud providers contributed to lower-than-expected AI infrastructure spending. Microsoft cut its annual capital expenditure forecast by $5 billion.
The news sent neocloud stocks tumbling, highlighting concerns that the young companies can't deliver on their multibillion-dollar promises.
Although Microsoft didn't name names, two data center projects from neoclouds Iren and Nebius could be responsible, according to satellite analysis from research firm Aterio.
In Texas, IREN is building four data centers under a $9.7 billion deal with Microsoft. An October 21 satellite flyover found that one of the buildings, Horizon 4, was still missing backup power generators and cooling equipment — and risked missing its scheduled delivery by the end of the year, Aterio said.
IREN previously said that equipment shortages had delayed the first building, Horizon 1, which Microsoft accepted in August.
Data center operator DataOne is developing the second project in New Jersey for Nebius under a $17.4 billion deal with Microsoft. Aterio said roughly 140 megawatts of that project's planned capacity could slip into 2027.
It struggled to get permits for its original power generators, then faced more approval delays after switching to fuel cells, said Aterio data analyst Daud Shiraz. Regulators fined DataOne $1 million in September for operating generators without the required permits.
The potential delays point to broader struggles. In October, Microsoft axed a deal with another neocloud, Nscale, due to power-supply delays.
The research firm Currence estimates that 30% to 50% of planned data center capacity initially scheduled to come online this year could be pushed into 2027 or later due to electricity shortages and other construction issues.
A Microsoft spokesperson said its "approach to infrastructure is built on flexibility and optionality," combining its own data centers with leased facilities and third-party providers.
IREN and DataOne declined to comment for this story. Nebius did not respond to a request for comment from Business Insider.
Have a tip? Contact this reporter via email at gweiss@businessinsider.com or Signal at @geoffweiss.25. Use a personal email address, a non-work WiFi network, and a non-work device; here's our guide to sharing information securely.
Corning is investing $585 million in expanding manufacturing in North Carolina.
Travis Dove for The Washington Post via Getty Images
AI's growth demands denser optical networks, increasing the need for more fiber across data centers.
Hyperscalers like Meta are securing fiber supply through long-term deals with manufacturers.
Innovations like Relativity Networks' hollow-core fiber can increase data transmission speeds.
Data centers have long relied on fiber to transmit signals. But the compute necessary to meet AI's demand requires more fiber than ever before.
AI pulls from hundreds of thousands of servers and chips. Lauren Clark, a managing director in Brown Gibbons Lang & Company's infrastructure vertical, told Business Insider that the higher density of fiber, the faster computers can talk to each other— and the faster a large language model can provide a response.
And as AI models become more complex and sophisticated, they require denser optical networks, said Mike O'Day, senior vice president and general manager of Corning Optical Communications.
Without sufficient fiber, AI chatbots stall and show users a busy signal or error, which is already happening today. Longer-term, a lack of fiber could mean pricier tokens and longer adoption cycles because supplies are constrained, said Gordon Bell, a partner and principal leading digital infrastructure engagements at EY-Parthenon.
"You can't have AI for an end user without a powered data center. You can't have it without connectivity," Bell said. "They all need to come together at the same place at the same time in order for everything to work."
As AI models become more complex and enterprises and consumers use the technology daily, AI tools will require more infrastructure to respond to chatbot queries. To meet demand, hyperscalers — the companies that provide cloud computing and data storage such as Amazon and Meta — are locking in agreements with fiber manufacturers such as Corning. In turn, fiber suppliers are expanding manufacturing capacity, while some startups are developing technologies to send data at faster speeds. Both strategies reflect the industry's bet that fiber will be critical to keeping pace with AI's growth.
"There's just an insatiable demand for optical fiber," said Jason Eichenholz, the cofounder of Relativity Networks, an optical networking and fiber-optics startup.
AI changes the fiber game
For decades, optical fiber was a quiet corner of telecommunications, Clark said. When ChatGPT launched in 2022, it brought fiber into the spotlight.
"AI is the biggest change factor in data centers and digital infrastructure that we've seen since the origins of the industry," Clark said.
That demand is also reshaping how data centers are built. While single mega-facilities exist — like xAI's Colossus data center in Memphis, Tennessee — there are limits to how large one facility can be due to the amount of electricity and water needed to support each data center, Eichenholz said. Communities are also pushing back against this type of data center construction in their neighborhoods, he added.
The lack of mega-facilities means companies build multiple data centers with fiber connecting them, Bell said. Fiber gets data from point A to point B and connects GPUs and chips, allowing them to "function essentially as one gigantic computer," Bell said.
The challenge to scaling up fiber supply lies in production capacity, Bell said. That includes making the fiber, sourcing connectors, testing the fiber, and the physical labor of laying fiber in the ground.
Additionally, non-data-center industries, such as office buildings, industrial sites, and residential homes, use fiber for connectivity — such as fiber-optic internet that many people use at home.
"Because of data centers increasing their demand for fiber, it is putting a strain on the overall system," Clark said. "There is definitely a dearth of supply that's going to trickle through the entire market." She said fiber orders today take twice as long to fill compared to roughly three years ago.
Solutions take shape
Hyperscalers are assessing if they can trust that fiber will be delivered on time and in the quantities they need, Bell said. To solve the crunch, tech giants and fiber manufacturers are signing enormous pre-commitments, Eichenholz said. "You're seeing massive multi-year, multibillion-dollar take-or-pay contracts on a product that was a commodity three years ago," he added.
Fiber manufacturers are scaling up capacity, but in a disciplined manner. They're locking in commitments from customers before they increase manufacturing and labor capacity, so that hyperscalers and suppliers share the costs and risks of expansion, Corning's O'Day said.
Corning is investing $585 million in expanding manufacturing in North Carolina. This year alone, the optical fiber manufacturer inked long-term agreements to supply fiber and cable to Amazon, Meta, and Nvidia. Last month, the company's optical communications division reported a 44% year-over-year jump in sales, while GenAI product sales more than doubled.
Corning's manufacturing facility in rural Midland, NC.
Travis Dove for The Washington Post via Getty Images
"Our customers are connecting enormous numbers of GPUs, and they need to fit much more fiber and many more connections into the same physical space," O'Day said.
Beyond agreements, fiber suppliers are innovating the product itself. O'Day said Corning has developed smaller-diameter fiber and denser cables that put more capacity within the same footprint. The company invented a fiber with a 40% smaller surface area that can bend into 10 times smaller spaces. That led to the development of its Contour Flow Cable, which Corning announced in March.
While incumbents like Corning are packing more fiber into limited spaces, new entrants are rethinking optical physics altogether.
Relativity Networks, an AI network startup, developed ChronoCore, a hollow-core fiber designed to bypass the physical speed limits of conventional glass. The fiber allows signals to travel at 99.7% the speed of light, Eichenholz said. He calls it "an HOV lane for fiber." By comparison, light moves through glass fiber at two-thirds the speed of light. Relativity is partnering with Prysmian, one of the world's largest producers of fiber-optic cables, to scale production.
The difference in speed matters when connecting data centers. Light traveling through traditional fiber has a slight delay, but the hollow core moves at nearly the speed of light, which means operators can build data centers farther apart without harming the performance of an AI model.
Relatively completed its first deployment with a major hyperscaler in 2024 and recently landed a $40 million order to connect data centers with the same hyperscaler.
Bell predicts the pace of data center buildouts will eventually level off. But he doesn't see the appetite for fiber shrinking in the near term.
"There's a lot of unknowns with respect to AI infrastructure," Bell said. "But the use of fiber is really kind of one of the highest conviction areas where I think we're going to clearly need more of."
Trump said that data center companies should pay a "dividend" to local communities.
Andrew Harnik/Getty Images
President Donald Trump said data center companies should pay a "dividend" to local communities.
In a Truth Social post, Trump said the payments could boost the controversial projects' popularity.
Data centers have sparked widespread public backlash, worrying some investors.
President Donald Trump said that data center companies should pay local communities a "dividend" to make their projects "popular."
In a Truth Social post early Wednesday, Trump urged companies to "MAKE DEALS," but did not provide details on how much money they should return to communities or individuals where data centers are being built.
"I have watched the process closely, and Data Centers that were highly unpopular in a certain area, have become extremely popular when a financial deal is struck," he wrote in the post.
There's been a growing backlash against data center construction across the US, with some saying the projects are noisy, raise electricity bills, and compromise the general quality of living.
Data centers are becoming an increasingly important issue in next month's midterm elections, and some politicians have shifted how they talk about the projects in recent months. Data Center Watch, a research project run by 10a Labs, found that in the first quarter of this year, at least 75 data center projects were delayed or canceled due to local opposition.
Some companies have already started trying to placate unhappy locals with money or discounts.
This summer, Elon Musk's SpaceX offered eligible Memphis residents a 50% discount on its Starlink internet service, tied to its growing AI build-out in the city. NorthPoint Development opted for a pure cash incentive and said it would pay every household in a Pennsylvania township $10,000 if it got permission to build a data center, the Wall Street Journal reported last month.
In his Wednesday post, Trump also referenced one of his previous efforts: having tech companies cover their power costs when they build data centers to help keep local electricity prices flat.
Several tech leaders agreed to do so in March, when they signed the "Ratepayer Protection Pledge," which mandates that companies provide or pay for the power generation and electricity needed for their AI projects, among other commitments.
Trump closed his Wednesday post by saying that building data centers under his newest stipulations would be "GREAT FOR THE U.S.A."
Rural Americans are antagonistic toward new data centers near them, according to a new Pew Research poll.
Bloomberg/Getty Images
A growing share of Americans living in rural areas aren't happy with data centers.
Most data centers are built in rural areas.
Data centers are facing a public reckoning amid bipartisan pushback.
Americans living in rural areas are increasingly souring on data centers.
In a new poll by the Pew Research Center, which surveyed people in August, half of rural Americans said data centers "are mostly bad for the environment" — a figure substantially higher than in January, when it sat at 32%.
46% of those respondents also said that data centers would drive up home energy costs, up from 32% in January. 45% said they negatively impact the quality of life for those living nearby, while 28% said so in January.
While displeasure with data centers increased among Americans across the board, according to Pew, higher levels of antagonism among rural voters are striking because most data centers are built in rural areas.
The data center buildout, which proponents say is integral for the US to keep pace with China in the AI race, has been suffering a PR crisis as a bipartisan coalition of lawmakers moves to impose limits on data center construction.
Texas Gov. Greg Abbot, who was formerly bullish about building data centers in his state, recently backed away from that optimism. His administration has halted some 1,800 AI data center projects in the state.
All across the country, Americans are rallying to fight against AI data centers, which can cost billions to build and span hundreds of acres. Many are concerned about how the sprawling facilities will affect the environment, utility prices, water resources, and noise levels. Some just don't like AI.
For AI companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta, Google, and others, the issue is existential. Without AI data centers, they can't power the products they sell. Sam Altman has recently suggested that new data centers could be built far from where people lived, such as the desert.
Proponents of data centers have said the buildout brings jobs to rural areas. Venture capitalist Gavin Baker recently said that data centers are "probably the best thing that has ever happened to working-class Americans."
Tech bros haven't been able to agree on exactly why Americans aren't taking to the data center buildout. Some have postulated that a Chinese-orchestrated psy-op is behind the distrust, while others said tech leaders haven't sold the product well.
President Donald Trump, for his part, called the data center buildout "the golden goose," and warned against falling behind China.
"The only reason that communities throughout the U.S.A. should not want Data Centers is if they want to end up being backwards and poor," Trump said in August in a Truth Social post.
In the Pew poll, very few Americans — about 4% — said data centers are "good" for the environment, energy costs, and quality of life.
"Americans have grown more negative toward the possible environmental and economic effects of data centers since the beginning of the year," Pew said in a release. "And a majority say they'd be uncomfortable if a new data center started operating in their area."